Horn mouth termination
In this thread
http://www.hostboard.com/forums/alte...ml#post1775827
I mentioned my experiments with soft termination of the mouth edges or "lips" of the Altec 811. Documented somewhat in this diyAudio thread diyAudio Forums - Horn Honk and Towels - Page 1
Basically I started out with rolled up beach towels draped around the mouth of the 811. The result was subtle, but audible. It sounded like something went away. In fact it did, a kink in the FR at ~1 KHz. The effect was twice as pronounced with towels top and bottom as with just one. The sound was overall smoother.
I also used some pipe insulation, the black foam stuff that I picked up at a local HVAC store. It worked well, but was hard to make pretty. Ended up with tubes sewn out of gray flannel stuffed with Dacron fiber.
The idea is to easy the impedance change from the horn mouth to free air. If the change is too abrupt, it causes diffraction artifacts that are audible. Using a lossy material to gradually easy from hard metal to soft air seems to work well.
I wanted to build a good rollover with chicken wire or hardware cloth covered with felt, but never did.
This tweak does make a difference and is worth the effort. Cost is very low. Have fun with it!
I'll try to post a pic tonight....I used some felt fabric that I rolled up
and used...he he...some paper clips to hold it in place just to listen.
I need to repeat the test because my hearing was already used up
yesterday but I thought it deadened the sparkle and lowered the horn sound.
Maybe the key is to use as little as possible and maybe that's why I see it used
so sparingly in the applications that are out there. Obviously this is fairly
obscure territory to be wading in...
For more info you might do a search on 'HOM' 'Higher Order Modes' (IIRC). May be the same thing.
I believe it'd get you into a discussion of 'mouth reflections' and the signals bouncing around the horn, arriving out of time with the original.
Topics RE the UREI 604 monitors (?) with the foam CD horn might also apply.
HOMs are reflections inside the horn that comb filter with the direct radiation not unlike what happens when speakers generate early reflections off the room's various boundaries. Mouth generated reflections are both spurious (HOMs 'ringing' off the lips such as bell modes) and eigenmodes (standing waves) across it that cause reflections back to the throat (or at least the first fold), modulating it.Originally Posted by gearfreak
Dr.Geddes's foam insert quells the HOMs and the Tractrix, Jean-Michel Le Cl?ac'h terminations as well as Peavey's foam 'lip' or similar do a good job of dealing with the eigenmodes.
GM
Loud is Beautiful if it's Clean! As always though, the usual disclaimers apply to this post's contents.
HOMs are a bit different and relate more to reflections generated in the throat of horn.
You should not lose sparkle with the soft lips, but you will hear the loss of something. That something is generally a kink in the midrange. Response should be flatter - and better of axis too - with the edge treament.
As long as you are not blocking the sound path and you hear less of something, that's probably a good thing. =) Live with it a bit to see what you think.
EDIT: OH, GM posted before me. He says it well.
Rather than trying to fix some kind of damping 'thing' around the horn mouth, would adhering a thin acoustically absorbent material like felt or suede even, to the last few inches of the actual horn surface give the desired result?
I've tried to illustrate what I mean in the attached image.
I see what you mean and it's certainly a more elegant approach...
However it may not do enough. Easy enough to test. Just try a couple of big towels to start (2 per horn). Then judge your own improvements by that standard.
http://www.superbadcat.com/images/stereo/511e_7.jpg
I think the horn sound is diminished...anyway something has
changed considerably to cause what I'm hearing. Talk about a low
cost tweak...just how d'ya get it done "best"?
i think the bells should be sculpted to have a curve not so abrupt.
I really think I should do that first and then experiment with the material lining.
Very interesting!
To use one of Bad Bob's favorite words...
"empirically, of course"
tweak, measure, tweak, measure, rinse, repeat. Last verse same as the first.
"[I]We're going all the way, till the wheels fall off and burn[/I]!"
Bob Dylan, from [I]Brownsville Girl[/I]
[I]"Time wounds all heels"[/I]
John Lennon, referring to the Nixon/Hoover deportation fiasco.
If it works on 511/811's, will it do the same on the horn section of a 828 cabinet? or is the wave length too long?
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks